Disney’s latest offering on Disney+, “Win or Lose,” deviates from the typical hero-villain dichotomy we are accustomed to in their films. Instead, the series challenges viewers to consider how perspectives can shift, blurring the lines between good and bad. The animation, courtesy of Pixar, is breathtaking, immersing viewers in a world filled with vivid light and texture that feels almost tangible.
Each of the eight episodes of “Win or Lose” follows a different character associated with the Pickles, an adolescent coed softball team. The creators, Carrie Hobson and Michael Yates, take storytelling to a new level by delving into the emotional experiences of each character. Insecurities manifest as tangible entities, daydreams appear as vivid cartoons, and the narrative weaves together like a jigsaw puzzle, leading up to a climactic event at the big game.
The series invites viewers to empathize with the characters, to look beyond surface-level judgments, and to appreciate the complexity of human emotions. It encourages patience, understanding, and the value of keeping an open mind and heart. However, despite its many merits, “Win or Lose” stumbles in its handling of a trans character, Kai, whose storyline was altered to make her cisgender.
The decision to change Kai’s identity undermines the very message of empathy and inclusivity that the series aims to convey. It misses an opportunity to show compassion towards trans children and their families, perpetuating a narrative that erases their experiences. Despite its standout qualities, the series falls short in living up to its own principles of thoughtful storytelling and understanding.
“Win or Lose” is a remarkable piece of work in many aspects, showcasing intelligence, beauty, and emotional depth. However, the misstep in handling Kai’s character detracts from its overall impact, highlighting the importance of staying true to inclusive narratives in storytelling. Disney’s reluctance to fully embrace diversity and representation ultimately contradicts the essence of the series, detracting from its otherwise commendable qualities.