Farewell to a Late-Night Sensation: Celebrating After Midnight
As the clock strikes 1:37 AM tonight, the curtain will officially fall on After Midnight, a groundbreaking late-night comedy series that evolved charmingly from its earlier incarnation as @midnight on Comedy Central. The show, which ran from 2013 to 2017, has found new life on CBS under the charismatic leadership of host Taylor Tomlinson. This finale ushers in an end to a significant chapter in televised humor, filled with spontaneous laughter, engaging games, and a unique camaraderie among comedians.
Reflecting on the Impact of After Midnight
At LateNighter, we will profoundly miss After Midnight. However, the expanse of comedians who graced the show will likely feel its absence even more. To capture their sentiments, we reached out to several participants, inviting them to share their thoughts about this distinctive comedy platform. Their replies ranged from humorous anecdotes to heartfelt reflections.
The Unique Charm of After Midnight
Paul F. Tompkins (10 appearances/5 wins):
“I was genuinely excited when I heard the show was coming back. It provided a rare opportunity—a real showcase for comedians on television once more. It’s unfortunate that such showcases are dwindling, but it was a joy while it lasted. The environment was relaxed, spontaneous, and infused with fun. Everyone involved, from the crew to the writers, made us feel appreciated and allowed for improvisation during performance.”
Lisa Gilroy (4 appearances/1 win):
After Midnight was like a McDonald’s PlayPlace for comedians: slightly chaotic, yet immensely enjoyable, where we had the freedom to play without supervision.”
Guy Branum (7 appearances/2 wins):
After Midnight was refreshing—a reboot that felt alive. Taylor Tomlinson and her team fostered an inclusive atmosphere, inviting creative chaos that regularly led to comedic magic.
Markella Arguello (5 appearances/2 wins):
“There are very few platforms, especially on TV, that encourage performers to showcase their authentic selves. This show stood out in that regard, promoting a diverse spectrum of comedy that challenged expectations.”
The Role of Taylor Tomlinson and Team Dynamics
Maria Bamford (7 appearances/2 wins):
“Taylor was an incredible host, running a supportive environment that allowed for creativity and low pressure. The energy she fostered was genuinely delightful, welcoming every comic with open arms.”
Kurt Braunohler (8 appearances/0 wins):
“Taylor’s remarkable presence and the support from the production team, including Jo Firestone and Marianne Ways, made After Midnight a rare treat in late-night television. It was the only major network show consistently pushing stand-up comedy into the spotlight.”
Memorable Moments from After Midnight
Comedians relished various memories from their time on the show. From playful competitions to unexpected humorous performances, memorable moments abound.
Paul F. Tompkins: “One of my fondest memories is when Tom Lennon and I stood on taller boxes next to Joe Manganiello, escalating our comedy routine in a hilarious fashion.”
Kurt Braunohler: “One time, after losing a game, I uniquely called my wife to humorously share the news, engaging my six-year-old while spinning a funny tale of being a disappointing father.”
Community and Camaraderie: The Backbone of After Midnight
The collaborative spirit among comedians and crew set After Midnight apart from other shows. Many comedians noted the supportive environment that encouraged risk-taking and impulsive humor.
Chris Fleming (5 appearances/0 wins):
“What amazed me most was the freedom given to performers. I appreciated that every request I made to the producers was received with enthusiasm—allowing us to indulge in playful creativity.”
Final Send-Off: After Midnight’s Series Finale
As the series continues to air its finale tonight at 12:37 AM, the legacy it leaves is clear. Comedians, fans, and every participant cherish the unique blend of chaos and creativity that made After Midnight memorable.
Fans can catch the finale streaming the following day on Paramount+—a bittersweet farewell to a show that celebrated unpredictability and joy in comedy. The vibrant atmosphere that fueled After Midnight will live on in the hearts of both the comedians and the viewers.