The Oscars have long been a topic of debate when it comes to the deserving winners. While some films undoubtedly hit the mark, there are numerous instances where the recipients leave audiences scratching their heads. As we gear up for the 2025 ceremony, let’s take a look back at 15 films that arguably should not have clinched the prestigious Oscar.
Slumdog Millionaire (2008)
- Number of Wins: Eight
- Despite its initial acclaim, Danny Boyle’s "Slumdog Millionaire" has lost its shine over time. The Best Picture victory of this film over the likes of "The Dark Knight" raised eyebrows and left many questioning the Academy’s judgment.
The Imitation Game (2014)
- Number of Wins: One
- “The Imitation Game” may have secured a win for Adapted Screenplay, but its shallow portrayal of Alan Turing’s story fell short of capturing the depth and nuance it deserved.
Irma la Douce (1963)
- Number of Wins: One
- Billy Wilder’s "Irma la Douce" failed to live up to the standards set by its predecessors. While it had its moments, the film’s win for André Previn’s score left much to be desired compared to other contenders like "Sundays and Cybèle."
Out of Africa (1985)
- Number of Wins: Seven
- Sydney Pollack’s "Out of Africa" garnered praise for performances and visuals but stumbled in its romanticized portrayal of colonialism. Films like "Witness" resonated more with audiences and critics in 1985.
In Old Arizona (1928)
- Number of Wins: One
- An early Oscar winner, "In Old Arizona," failed to impress with its uninspired storytelling and lackluster dialogue, making it a forgettable entry in the winner’s list.
Chariots of Fire (1981)
- Number of Wins: Four
- While "Chariots of Fire" checked many Academy boxes, its victory over more deserving contenders like "Reds" left many questioning its win for Best Picture.
Green Book (2018)
- Number of Wins: Three
- "Green Book" sparked controversy with its Best Picture win over critical darling "Roma," dividing audiences and critics over its handling of complex themes.
How the West Was Won (1962)
- Number of Wins: Three
- Despite technical achievements, "How the West Was Won" failed to stand the test of time as a Western classic, falling short compared to the genre’s true champions.
The Iron Lady (2011)
- Number of Wins: Two
- Meryl Streep’s portrayal in "The Iron Lady" raised eyebrows with its win, overshadowing more nuanced performances like Viola Davis’ in "The Help."
- Suicide Squad (2016)
- Number of Wins: One
- Despite its flaws, "Suicide Squad" managed to nab an Oscar for Makeup and Hairstyling, a surprising victory for a film that divided audiences and critics alike.
While the Oscars aim to celebrate cinematic excellence, the list of questionable winners highlights the subjective nature of awards. As we anticipate the upcoming ceremony, let’s reflect on these past films that may not have aged as gracefully as their golden statuettes suggest.